I’ve been an avid Kriega backpack user for many, many years but have yet to EVER own a full size Messenger style bag. I do have a Trip Machine shoulder bag, but its too small for my iPad and other bits & pieces.

I was wondering if anyone here has some input or maybe some other recommendations re. mid to full size, comfortable Messenger bags.

I have read lots about many different types and my choices are (in descending order):

1) Kriega Messenger EDC

2) Merlin Cheadle (in black)

3) Vanquest Gen4

4) 5.11 tactical Mike

I don’t really need a 100% watertight bag nor do
I want a “look at me” Louis Vuitton or boring Tumi, but instead I’m just looking to add something fun, usable & rugged to my collection.

I look forward to hearing your opinions & input.

Not a messenger bag exactly but I love Maxpedition stuff, so always sling this one over my shoulder.

It's big enough to carry all my essentials I like to ride with and if I call into the store I can even squeeze in a bottle of wine and some cheese if needs be..

Not too heavy or bulky either, so hardly notice it when riding.

Lilli doesn't fit in it but she's so cute had to include her in the pic.

Cheerio,

Roy

Attached Thumbnails

 

Thanks Roy, I’ll take a look.

I have a man purse that is near identical to this, it has served me well and has been on many traveling trips.

And these, well mine does, has a Velcro loop to go around you belt to limit movement.

I've always been a fan of the Timbuk2 Classic Messenger bag. I've had one that I've used for years, and I bought a back-up when they were on sale on Amazon for when the time comes that my initial bag no longer holds up. So far, the back-up is still in its plastic bag. Great bag, and I really like that it has a large clip that allows the bag to be worn firmly on your back and then, when unclicked, it drops nicely down at your side. I'm a simple "black bag" guy, but there are a variety of colors available as well, if you're into making more of a statement. Reasonably priced too.

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0...?ie=UTF8&psc=1

I don’t have any additional suggestions for you eisen but out of the 4 you’re currently looking at and the requirement you have I’d feel drawn to the 5.11 tactical mike.

It just looks a little more rugged, appears to be very fit for purpose, is competitively priced and I have tons of 5.11 gear so no the quality to be of a very high standard.

Which way are you leaning out of the 4?

Thanks Mike & Ysoslo.
I’m leaning towards the Merlin and Vanquest at the moment.
I have been mighty impressed with the Merlin gear I’ve purchased so far and price/quality ratio is outstanding.
Vanquest are new to me, but seems to get raving reviews from hardcore travelers.

I like the look of a traditional hunting/cartridge bag like this barbour but find that bags slung over my shoulder tend to slide round and then I always feel like I'm adjusting them all the time - I reckon it's my sloping caveman shoulders rather than the bag's fault. For that reason, I tend to favour a back pack or ruck sack.

I've been very impressed with my XLmoto waterproof backpack that I picked up for £30 when it was on sale (it frequently is). The rubberised material has led up very well, it's spacious and the roll top is nice and secure. The straps and padding are perhaps a little thin but I've never found it uncomfortable as it's worn over my gear anyway. Although roomy enough for carrying a laptop, there are no inner compartments but I have a slimline padded case for mine so I would still be protected. This Shad bag which is waiting on a full description is new to the site but looks to be the same roll-top, rubberised materials. They also do a 'Vintage' canvas Messenger Bag which looks quite nice but I assume is not waterproof (more necessary in Blighty than other, drier climates).

Of your choices, I think the Kriega is the one I'd spring for - it's a bit boring to look at but their quality is hard to beat.

I think they're both great, but out of the two the Merlin gets my vote, as I think it fits the Bobber's retro aesthetic much better.

Also like that Merlin for its vintage look which is in keeping with the Bobber aesthetic. Normally I wouldn’t favor a messenger bag over a backpack (my favorites are Burly, only water resistant though, and Velomacchi, pricey but it’s unique clasp is very functional) but, the Merlin has a waist strap which takes away some of my concern with shoulder slippage. Plus it just looks cool.